Complete List Of Highly Suspect Band Members

Feature Photo: Roberta, CC BY 2.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0>, via Wikimedia Commons

From humble beginnings in the bars of Cape Cod to Grammy nominations and chart-topping singles, Highly Suspect has carved out a distinctive place in contemporary rock music. Formed in 2009, the band initially performed covers of rock legends like Sublime, Jimi Hendrix, and Pink Floyd in local venues around Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

What began as three friends playing for bar crowds has evolved into a formidable rock outfit with six full-length releases to their name: the self-released Highly Suspect (2011), followed by five major-label studio albums—Mister Asylum (2015), The Boy Who Died Wolf (2016), MCID (2019), The Midnight Demon Club (2022), and As Above, So Below (2024). Their sound has continuously evolved, initially drawing from alternative rock, hard rock, and blues rock before incorporating elements of hip-hop, pop, and electronic music in later releases.

The band’s breakthrough came with their 2015 major-label debut “Mister Asylum,” which earned them nominations for Best Rock Album and Best Rock Song (“Lydia”) at the 58th Grammy Awards. Their follow-up album “The Boy Who Died Wolf” further solidified their success with “My Name Is Human” reaching number one on the Billboard US Mainstream Rock Songs chart.

Throughout their career, Highly Suspect has maintained a fiercely independent approach to their art, often pushing genre boundaries and defying conventional expectations. Originally a trio consisting of Johnny Stevens and twin brothers Rich and Ryan Meyer, the band expanded to include Matt Kofos and later Mark Schwartz, broadening their sonic palette and evolving their live performances.

The band’s fanbase, affectionately known as “MCID” (My Crew Is Dope), has grown from local Cape Cod supporters to a global following. From playing small bars to performing at major music festivals like Lollapalooza, Bonnaroo, and SXSW, Highly Suspect has maintained their distinctive voice while continuing to evolve musically.

Their journey represents a quintessential rock success story of the 2010s and 2020s: independent artists building a grassroots following through relentless touring and authentic expression, ultimately breaking through to mainstream success without compromising their artistic vision.

Highly Suspect remained active in 2026, releasing the singles “Yellow Roses,” “Wasted,” and “Big Shop of Horrors.” They also joined Yelawolf for the co-headlining War Within Tour, which ran through September and October. The new music and continued touring showed that the five-member group was still building on the success of As Above, So Below.

Johnny Stevens

Johnny Stevens, born April 10, 1986, in Cape Cod, Massachusetts, is the founding lead vocalist, guitarist, and principal songwriter of Highly Suspect. Before establishing the band, Stevens worked as a plumber while nurturing his musical ambitions through local performances.

In 2009, he formed Highly Suspect with twins Rich and Ryan Meyer, longtime friends and fellow graduates of Dennis-Yarmouth Regional High School. Stevens serves as the band’s creative centerpiece, contributing lead vocals, guitar, synthesizer, and piano across all Highly Suspect releases from their earliest EPs through their self-released 2011 full-length and five subsequent major-label studio albums.

Stevens’ distinct vocal style and candid, introspective songwriting have become defining characteristics of Highly Suspect’s sound. His personal experiences often inform the band’s lyrics, most notably on “Mister Asylum,” which explores his struggles with anxiety and panic attacks that began when he was 25.

As the band’s sound evolved, Stevens’ creative vision expanded to incorporate diverse musical influences, particularly evident on 2019’s “MCID,” where he introduced a hip-hop alter ego called “Terrible Johnny” and collaborated with artists outside the rock genre, including rapper Young Thug on the track “Tokyo Ghoul.”

Beyond Highly Suspect, Stevens has pursued additional creative outlets and business ventures. He actively engages with fans through social media under the moniker “Terrible Johnny,” building a loyal community around the band’s music. His entrepreneurial spirit and artistic versatility have helped Highly Suspect maintain relevance in a rapidly changing music industry.

Throughout the band’s evolution from a bar cover band to a Grammy-nominated rock act, Stevens has remained the constant driving force, continuously pushing boundaries and exploring new sonic territories while maintaining the raw energy and authenticity that first connected with audiences in Cape Cod’s local venues.

Rich Meyer

Rich Meyer, born in Cape Cod, Massachusetts, is a founding member of Highly Suspect who has been with the band since its formation in 2009. As the bassist and backing vocalist, Rich creates the harmonic foundation that anchors the band’s sound across all their releases. Along with his twin brother Ryan on drums, Rich forms half of the rhythm section that has powered Highly Suspect from their earliest performances in Cape Cod bars through their rise to Grammy-nominated rock act.

He has performed on all of the band’s recordings, from their early EPs like “First Offense” (2009) and “The Gang Lion” (2010) through their major studio albums including “Mister Asylum” (2015), “The Boy Who Died Wolf” (2016), “MCID” (2019), “The Midnight Demon Club” (2022), and “As Above, So Below” (2024).

Rich’s bass playing combines technical proficiency with a feel for groove, providing both rhythmic stability and melodic counterpoint to Johnny Stevens’ guitar work. His contributions to songs like “Lydia” and “My Name Is Human” helped propel these singles to chart success and critical acclaim. Beyond his instrumental role, Rich’s backing vocals add depth and dimension to the band’s sound, particularly in live performances where the interplay between his voice and Johnny’s leads creates dynamic tension and release.

Outside of Highly Suspect, Rich has maintained a relatively private profile compared to frontman Johnny Stevens. His close musical partnership with his twin brother Ryan creates a unique synergy in the rhythm section that has been essential to the band’s distinctive sound.

From the band’s earliest days playing covers in local establishments to performing at major festivals and venues around the world, Rich Meyer has been a steady presence, his bass work evolving alongside the band’s expanding sonic palette while maintaining the raw energy that first connected with audiences in their hometown of Cape Cod.

Ryan Meyer

Ryan Meyer, born in Cape Cod, Massachusetts, has been the rhythmic foundation of Highly Suspect since co-founding the band with his twin brother Rich and Johnny Stevens in 2009. As the drummer and backing vocalist, Ryan has shaped the band’s percussive identity across all their recordings and performances.

His drumming style balances technical precision with raw power, adapting to the band’s evolution from straightforward rock to more experimental soundscapes on later albums. Ryan has performed on every Highly Suspect release, from their early EPs like “First Offense” (2009) and “The Gang Lion” (2010) through their full-length albums including “Mister Asylum” (2015), “The Boy Who Died Wolf” (2016), “MCID” (2019), “The Midnight Demon Club” (2022), and “As Above, So Below” (2024).

Ryan’s contributions extend beyond drumming to include backing vocals, adding depth to the band’s harmonies and supporting Johnny Stevens’ lead vocals. The chemistry between Ryan and his twin brother Rich creates a uniquely cohesive rhythm section that has been crucial to Highly Suspect’s sound, particularly evident on tracks like “Lydia,” “My Name Is Human,” and “16.” His adaptability as a drummer has allowed the band to explore different genres and styles while maintaining their distinctive identity, from the blues-rock foundations of their earlier work to the hip-hop influenced beats on “MCID” and beyond.

Like his brother Rich, Ryan maintains a relatively low public profile compared to frontman Johnny Stevens, focusing primarily on his musical contributions rather than his public persona. Together with Rich and Johnny, Ryan has journeyed from playing covers in Cape Cod bars to performing at major festivals and venues worldwide, earning Grammy nominations and chart success along the way.

His steady presence behind the kit has been a constant through the band’s evolution, providing the rhythmic backbone for Highly Suspect’s ever-expanding sonic experiments while keeping them grounded in the raw energy of their rock roots.

Matt Kofos

Matt Kofos joined Highly Suspect as their lead guitarist, expanding the original trio into a quartet and bringing new dimensions to the band’s sound. After working with the group as a touring musician, Kofos became a full-time member in 2019 as they prepared their third major-label album, MCID.

He continued with the band through subsequent releases including The Midnight Demon Club (2022) and As Above, So Below (2024). His addition to the lineup marked a significant expansion of Highly Suspect’s sound, allowing for more complex guitar arrangements and freeing frontman Johnny Stevens to explore different vocal and performance approaches.

Kofos contributes guitar, synthesizer, percussion, and backing vocals to Highly Suspect’s sonic palette. In a 2019 interview with When The Horn Blows about the album “MCID,” Kofos spoke about the band’s decision to explore beyond rock music boundaries, noting the importance of creative evolution to their “mental health as a band.” This perspective highlights his role in the group’s artistic development during a period when they were actively pushing into new territory. His technical skills have allowed the band to execute more ambitious musical arrangements in both studio recordings and live performances.

While maintaining a lower public profile than frontman Johnny Stevens, Kofos has become an integral part of Highly Suspect’s current identity. His seamless integration into the band demonstrates his versatility as a musician, adapting to their established sound while helping to push it in new directions.

As a relatively newer member compared to the founding trio, Kofos represents the band’s willingness to evolve and grow beyond their original configuration, bringing fresh perspectives to their creative process while respecting the foundation built by Stevens and the Meyer twins.

Mark Schwartz

Mark Schwartz joined Highly Suspect full-time in 2019, alongside Matt Kofos, as a multi-instrumentalist focusing primarily on keyboards, synthesizers, and guitars. He had previously worked with the group as a touring musician and became part of the full lineup during the MCID era.

He continued with the band through The Midnight Demon Club (2022) and As Above, So Below (2024). His addition to Highly Suspect represents a further expansion of their sonic capabilities, particularly in electronic and atmospheric elements that have become more prominent in their recent work.

Schwartz’s contributions have helped Highly Suspect incorporate more diverse soundscapes into their music, building on the genre-blending approach they began exploring with “MCID.” His keyboard and synthesizer work has added new textural dimensions to the band’s sound, complementing their traditional rock instrumentation with electronic elements. This expanded palette has allowed the band to continue pushing creative boundaries while maintaining their distinctive identity. In live performances, Schwartz’s presence enables more faithful recreations of their increasingly complex studio arrangements.

As the fifth member in what began as a power trio, Schwartz represents Highly Suspect’s continuing evolution and willingness to expand both their lineup and their sound. His role supports the band’s trajectory toward more ambitious musical territory while maintaining connections to their rock foundations.

Though he maintains a relatively low public profile compared to founding members, Schwartz has become an integral part of Highly Suspect’s current incarnation, contributing to their position as a forward-thinking rock band willing to incorporate diverse influences and instrumentation.