Feature Photo: shahin khalaji
Breakup songs have always had a way of saying what people sometimes cannot put into words themselves. Some deal with the shock of knowing a relationship is over, while others look back with regret, anger, acceptance, or even relief. This list starts in that difficult place and gradually moves toward songs about letting go and getting on with life.
The choices range from Eric Carmen and Dionne Warwick to Leonard Cohen, Stevie Nicks, Harry Nilsson, and Tom Petty. They do not all approach heartbreak the same way, and that is exactly the point. Sometimes you need a song that understands the pain, and sometimes you need one that tells you it is time to move on.
# 10 – “Boats Against the Current” – Eric Carmen
Eric Carmen released “Boats Against the Current” as the title track of his 1977 album. The title was inspired by the closing line of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, and the song carries that same feeling of trying to move forward while still being pulled back by the past. Carmen reportedly connected the song to the end of his working relationship with producer Jimmy Ienner, but its sense of loss and separation works just as powerfully as a breakup song.
Read More: Top 10 Eric Carmen Songs
# 9 – “I’ll Never Fall in Love Again” – Dionne Warwick
Dionne Warwick’s “I’ll Never Fall in Love Again” was written by Burt Bacharach and Hal David for the musical Promises, Promises. Warwick released her version in 1969, and it reached No. 6 on the Billboard Hot 100 while spending three weeks at No. 1 on the Easy Listening chart. What makes the song work so well after a breakup is its humor: instead of collapsing under the sadness, Warwick delivers the disappointment with a knowing smile and just enough sarcasm to take some of the sting out of it.
Read More: Top 10 Dionne Warwick Songs
# 8 – “My Lonely Sad Eyes” – Maria McKee
Maria McKee recorded “My Lonely Sad Eyes” for her 1993 album You Gotta Sin to Get Saved. Van Morrison wrote the song and first recorded it with Them for the 1966 album Them Again. McKee’s version keeps the loneliness at the center of the song, and her vocal makes the title sound less like a description than a confession. It is a good choice for that stage after a breakup when there is nothing to celebrate yet and all you really want is a record that understands the mood.
Read More: 10 Maria McKee Songs That Will Leave You Mesmerized
# 7 – “It’s Over” – Rod Stewart
Rod Stewart released “It’s Over” on his 2013 album Time, the record that marked his return to writing original material after many years. Stewart has said the song came to him while he was working on his autobiography, and its subject is divorce and separation. Rather than dressing the breakup up as something romantic, he writes about the wreckage left behind when a marriage ends—the lost plans, the arguments, and the effect on the family—which gives the song a very different weight from the usual broken-heart ballad.
Read More: Top 10 Rod Stewart Songs
# 6 – “I Don’t Need You Anymore” – The Kinks
“I Don’t Need You Anymore” is an early Ray Davies song recorded by the Kinks in 1964 as a demo and not officially issued at the time. The recording eventually surfaced decades later on archival and deluxe releases. There is nothing complicated about the message: the narrator once thought losing this person would destroy him, but now he has reached the point where he can finally say he does not need her anymore. That directness makes the song an ideal turning point on this list.
Read More: Dave Davies of The Kinks: The ClassicRockHistory.com Interview
# 5 – “Hey, That’s No Way to Say Goodbye” – Leonard Cohen
Leonard Cohen’s “Hey, That’s No Way to Say Goodbye” appeared on his 1967 debut album, Songs of Leonard Cohen, after Judy Collins had already recorded the song for Wildflowers. Cohen does not turn the separation into a fight or a declaration of independence. He sounds like a man trying to leave something important without pretending it meant nothing, and that restraint is what gives the song so much emotional force.
Read More: Top 10 Leonard Cohen Songs
# 4 – “We Just Disagree” – Dave Mason
Dave Mason released “We Just Disagree” in 1977 on Let It Flow. Written by guitarist Jim Krueger, who also played the distinctive 12-string guitar and sang harmony on the recording, the song reached No. 12 on the Billboard Hot 100. Its appeal is right there in the chorus: there does not have to be a villain every time two people split up. Sometimes two people simply reach the point where they no longer see things the same way, and few breakup songs have ever said that more plainly.
Read More: Top 10 Dave Mason Songs
# 3 – “Wild Heart” – Stevie Nicks
“Wild Heart” opens Stevie Nicks’ 1983 album The Wild Heart. Nicks wrote the song in New York and later added an introduction dedicated to her close friend Robin Anderson, who had died shortly before the album was recorded. It is not a conventional breakup song, but its images of a damaged heart, emotional upheaval, and survival make it belong here. Nicks has described the song as moving through a nervous breakdown, recovery, and survival, which gives it a deeper meaning than a simple story about romance gone wrong.
Read More: Stevie Nicks’ Best Song On Each Of Her Albums
# 2 – “Everybody’s Talkin'” – Harry Nilsson
Fred Neil wrote and recorded “Everybody’s Talkin’,” but Harry Nilsson’s version became the famous one after it was used in the 1969 film Midnight Cowboy. Nilsson’s recording reached No. 6 on the Billboard Hot 100 and won him a Grammy. The song is not specifically about a breakup; it is about shutting out the noise and leaving for somewhere that feels better. That desire to get away and start over is exactly why it works so well here.
Read More: Top 10 Harry Nilsson Songs
# 1 – “Time to Move On” – Tom Petty
Tom Petty’s “Time to Move On” comes from his 1994 solo album Wildflowers and was produced by Rick Rubin. Petty never needs to explain exactly what happened or tell the listener how to feel about it. The title says enough. After all the looking back, arguing, hurting, and trying to understand what went wrong, there eventually comes a point when staying in the same place hurts more than leaving it. That is why “Time to Move On” belongs at No. 1.
Read More: Top 10 Tom Petty And The Heartbreakers Songs
For more from the artists on this list, take a look at our Top 10 Eric Carmen Songs, Top 10 Dionne Warwick Songs, and Top 10 Tom Petty And The Heartbreakers Songs.
Updated September 13, 2026.
10 Best Breakup Songs for Shattered Hearts article published on ClassicRockHistory.com © 2026
I would add “How Can You Mend A Broken Heart” by the amazingly harmonious Bee Gees, and the introspective lyrics.
“I can still feel the breeze that rustles through the trees
And misty memories of days gone by.
But we could never see tomorrow
Would you believe that no one, no one ever told us about the sorrow?
So how can you mend a broken heart? “