20 Worst Christmas Songs By Great Bands And Artists

Worst Christmas Songs By Great Bands And Artists

Feature Photo: Mikhail Sedov/ Shutterstock.com

Christmas is supposed to be the most wonderful time of the year, and when it comes to music, there are plenty of great songs that help make the holiday season special. However, not every Christmas record deserves to be played year after year. Some of the greatest rock bands and solo artists in music history have released holiday songs that make you wonder what they were thinking. We are talking about legendary performers who have given us some of the greatest albums and singles of all time, only to turn around and record Christmas music that sounds nothing like the material that made us love them in the first place.

I have always found it fascinating how Christmas music seems to bring out a completely different side of musicians. Sometimes that works beautifully. Other times, we get rock stars singing like lounge entertainers, heavy guitar bands suddenly sounding like children’s television performers, and legendary songwriters coming up with holiday compositions that probably should have remained in the recording studio. Of course, some people love these records. That’s part of the fun of putting together a list like this. One person’s treasured Christmas classic is another person’s reason to change the radio station.

Our list of the 20 worst Christmas songs by great bands and solo artists is meant to have a little fun with some musicians we genuinely admire. These are not bad artists. In fact, that is the entire point of the article. Every performer on this list has recorded music far better than the Christmas song we have chosen. We have included some ridiculous novelty recordings, some overly sentimental ballads, and a few attempts to bring holiday music into musical styles where it just doesn’t seem to belong. There are even a couple of songs that became enormous holiday favorites despite our objections. So pour yourself some eggnog, turn up the speakers, and prepare for a Christmas countdown that may have you reaching for the skip button.

# 20 – Santa’s Beard – The Beach Boys

Let’s begin with a band that should have been able to record one of the greatest Christmas albums of all time. The Beach Boys had Brian Wilson, those incredible harmonies, and a musical style that could make almost anything sound magical. Unfortunately, “Santa’s Beard” is one of those songs that makes me wonder how a group so talented could come up with something so silly. The music has that familiar Beach Boys charm, but the lyrics sound like something written for a children’s television show. I love the Beach Boys, but this one has always seemed a little too childish, even for a Christmas record.

“Santa’s Beard” appeared on The Beach Boys’ Christmas Album, released in November 1964. Brian Wilson and Mike Love wrote the song, which tells the story of a young boy discovering that the department-store Santa isn’t the real thing. The Beach Boys actually recorded some wonderful Christmas music, especially “Little Saint Nick,” which remains a holiday classic. That makes “Santa’s Beard” even more disappointing. The group could deliver gorgeous vocal arrangements and unforgettable melodies, yet here they were singing about a child pulling off Santa’s beard. It’s a cute idea, but not one I need to hear every December.

# 19 – Christmas (Baby Please Come Home) – U2

I have always admired U2 for the passion they put into their music. Bono is a tremendous singer, and the band has recorded some of the most powerful rock songs of the past several decades. However, their version of “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)” has never done much for me. Bono attacks the song with the same dramatic intensity he brings to some of U2’s biggest anthems. That approach works wonderfully on records like “Where the Streets Have No Name,” but I don’t think it works quite as well here. The performance feels a little too serious and forced for a Christmas song that already had a nearly perfect original recording.

U2 recorded “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)” for the 1987 charity compilation A Very Special Christmas, which benefited Special Olympics. The song was written by Phil Spector, Jeff Barry, and Ellie Greenwich and made famous by Darlene Love in 1963. Love even contributed background vocals to U2’s version and has spoken very highly of their recording. Clearly, my opinion is not shared by everyone. Still, I would much rather hear Love’s original performance. It has a musical excitement and emotional warmth that U2’s interpretation never quite captures for me.

# 18 – DJ Play a Christmas Song – Cher

Cher has reinvented herself so many times that I suppose we shouldn’t be surprised she eventually decided to turn Christmas into a dance-club event. “DJ Play a Christmas Song” sounds like something that belongs in a nightclub at two in the morning rather than around a Christmas tree. The pounding electronic beat, glossy production, and repetitive chorus make this one a difficult listen for me. I know Cher has always been able to cross musical boundaries, but this recording feels more like an attempt to create another dance hit than a memorable Christmas song. And once that chorus gets stuck in your head, good luck getting it out.

“DJ Play a Christmas Song” was released in October 2023 as the lead single from Cher’s first Christmas album, appropriately titled Christmas. The recording was a commercial success, reaching number one on Billboard’s Adult Contemporary chart and returning Cher to the Billboard Hot 100. That was quite an accomplishment for an artist whose career began in the 1960s. However, commercial success doesn’t necessarily make a recording great. Cher has one of the most recognizable voices in popular music, and I would have loved to hear her tackle something with a little more substance. Instead, we got Christmas disco with enough electronic production to keep Santa dancing until New Year’s Eve.

# 17 – Jingle Bells – Eric Clapton

There are certain musical combinations that make perfect sense. Eric Clapton playing the blues is one of them. Eric Clapton playing electronic dance music is another story entirely. His version of “Jingle Bells” is one of the strangest recordings I have ever heard from the legendary guitarist. Instead of the bluesy Christmas arrangement you might expect, the song features an electronic dance beat that sounds completely removed from Clapton’s musical identity. I kept waiting for one of those great guitar solos to rescue the performance. Unfortunately, the electronic rhythm dominates the entire recording. It is difficult to believe this came from the same musician who gave us “Layla” and “Wonderful Tonight.”

Clapton released “Jingle Bells” on his 2018 holiday album Happy Xmas. The recording was subtitled “In Memory of Avicii,” in tribute to the Swedish DJ and electronic music producer who died earlier that year. That tribute was certainly a meaningful gesture, and the intention behind it deserves respect. Clapton worked with producer Simon Climie on the album, which otherwise featured a collection of blues-influenced Christmas standards. The unusual electronic arrangement makes “Jingle Bells” stand out dramatically from the rest of the record. Unfortunately, it stands out for the wrong reasons. I have nothing against electronic music, but I would much rather hear Clapton playing his guitar.

# 16 – Christmas Conga – Cyndi Lauper

Cyndi Lauper has always been one of the most entertaining personalities in pop music. Her colorful image and distinctive voice helped make songs like “Girls Just Want to Have Fun” and “Time After Time” unforgettable. Unfortunately, “Christmas Conga” sounds like an attempt to combine Christmas music with a tropical dance party that nobody asked for. The rhythm is lively, and Lauper certainly sounds enthusiastic, but the whole thing becomes a little exhausting after a while. I can imagine this playing at an office Christmas party where someone insists that everybody get up and form a conga line. That is usually the moment I start looking for the exit.

“Christmas Conga” appeared on Lauper’s 1998 holiday album Merry Christmas…Have a Nice Life. The album featured a mixture of traditional Christmas music and original compositions, often incorporating musical styles not usually associated with holiday recordings. Lauper has always enjoyed experimenting with different sounds, and the tropical rhythms of “Christmas Conga” certainly fit her adventurous personality. There is nothing wrong with trying something different, but the novelty wears thin for me. This is one Christmas song that sounds as if it would be more comfortable at a beach resort than in a living room with a decorated tree.

# 15 – Must Be Santa – Bob Dylan

Bob Dylan is one of the greatest songwriters in music history. Nobody can take that away from him. However, listening to his version of “Must Be Santa” makes me wonder whether he was having a little too much fun in the recording studio. This is Christmas music turned into a frantic polka party, complete with accordion and Dylan’s unmistakable gravelly vocals. The song moves along at such a ridiculous pace that it almost sounds like everybody is trying to finish before the Christmas dinner gets cold. I can’t decide whether Dylan was deliberately making a joke or genuinely believed this was a great holiday arrangement. Either way, I find it difficult to take seriously.

“Must Be Santa” appeared on Dylan’s 2009 album Christmas in the Heart. The song had been recorded by other artists decades earlier, but Dylan’s arrangement drew inspiration from the polka band Brave Combo. The album was released to benefit hunger-relief charities, giving the project a worthwhile purpose beyond the music itself. Dylan also filmed a wonderfully bizarre music video featuring a chaotic Christmas party. The video makes the recording even stranger, which I suppose was the point. Plenty of fans love this song because it is so different from ordinary holiday music. I understand the appeal, but I still think it sounds like a Christmas party that has gotten completely out of control.

# 14 – Ho, Ho, Ho (Who’d Be a Turkey at Christmas) – Elton John

Elton John has written some of the greatest melodies in rock and pop history, and he certainly knew how to make a Christmas record. “Step Into Christmas” remains one of the most enjoyable holiday songs of the 1970s. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for “Ho, Ho, Ho (Who’d Be a Turkey at Christmas).” Even the title sounds like something Elton and Bernie Taupin came up with after a Christmas party had gone on a little too long. The recording has a goofy atmosphere that makes it difficult to believe it came from the same songwriting team responsible for “Your Song,” “Tiny Dancer,” and “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road.” It’s silly, messy, and not particularly memorable.

Elton John and Bernie Taupin wrote “Ho, Ho, Ho (Who’d Be a Turkey at Christmas)” in November 1973. It was released as the B-side of the much more successful “Step Into Christmas.” Both songs were written and recorded during the same brief period, with producer Gus Dudgeon involved in the sessions. Unlike the cheerful atmosphere of “Step Into Christmas,” this recording takes a more irreverent approach to the holiday season. It eventually appeared on several Elton John compilations and reissues. I understand the appeal of a musician letting loose and having some fun, but this is one B-side that probably deserved to remain a curiosity for collectors.

# 13 – Santa Baby – Madonna

I have always thought Eartha Kitt’s original recording of “Santa Baby” was brilliant. It was playful, sophisticated, and delivered with just the right amount of humor. Madonna took a very different approach when she recorded the song in 1987. Instead of using her natural singing voice, she adopted an exaggerated, childlike delivery that makes the entire performance sound like a cartoon character asking Santa for presents. I understand what she was trying to do, but that doesn’t mean I want to hear it. Madonna has recorded some fantastic pop songs, yet this version of “Santa Baby” has always seemed more annoying than entertaining to me.

Madonna recorded “Santa Baby” for the 1987 charity compilation A Very Special Christmas. The song was originally written by Joan Javits and Philip Springer, with additional songwriting credit associated with Tony Springer, and became famous through Eartha Kitt’s 1953 recording. Madonna’s version was produced by Jimmy Iovine and became one of the most recognizable interpretations of the song. Its exaggerated vocal style helped influence later novelty versions, although listeners remain divided over whether the performance is charming or irritating. Put me firmly in the second category. I would much rather hear Madonna singing “Holiday” than pretending to be a little girl talking to Santa Claus.

# 12 – Christmas Lights – Coldplay

Coldplay has always been a band that knows how to create emotional music, and Chris Martin has a voice that works beautifully with reflective melodies. However, sometimes you just want to hear a Christmas song that makes you feel good. “Christmas Lights” is not that song. The recording is so melancholy that I find it hard to get into the Christmas spirit while listening to it. There is a lovely melody buried inside the arrangement, but the mood is so gloomy that the holiday setting almost feels like an afterthought. If I am sitting in front of a Christmas tree with a cup of coffee, this isn’t exactly the song I want playing in the background.

Coldplay released “Christmas Lights” as a standalone single on December 1, 2010. The song was written by the band’s members and deals with the sadness of a relationship that has fallen apart during the holiday season. Its music video features a theatrical performance with Christmas decorations and elaborate lighting. The record became a seasonal favorite among Coldplay fans and eventually earned a regular place on holiday playlists. I understand why people enjoy its emotional atmosphere, but for me it leans too heavily into sadness. Christmas already comes with enough stress and complicated feelings. Sometimes I just want the music to provide a little escape from all that.

# 11 – We Wish You a Merry Christmas – Weezer

Weezer has recorded some wonderful power-pop songs, and I have always enjoyed the band’s ability to combine loud guitars with memorable melodies. However, their version of “We Wish You a Merry Christmas” seems like a rather unnecessary exercise. They take a traditional Christmas carol, add distorted guitars, and play it pretty much the way you would expect Weezer to play it. That’s the problem. There is very little imagination in the arrangement. It sounds like the band decided to knock out a Christmas record without spending much time figuring out what to do with the material. The result is pleasant enough, but it doesn’t give me any reason to choose this version over the thousands of others.

“We Wish You a Merry Christmas” appeared on the 2008 EP Christmas with Weezer. The project originally grew out of music recorded for a holiday edition of the mobile game Tap Tap Revenge. Weezer recorded six traditional Christmas songs for the release, applying the band’s familiar guitar-driven sound to the arrangements. Drummer Patrick Wilson played a significant role in recording the instrumental tracks, including guitar parts. The EP became a novelty addition to the band’s discography. It may appeal to Weezer fans looking for something different during the holidays, but I would much rather hear the group playing “Buddy Holly” or “Say It Ain’t So.”

# 10 – I Wanna Be Santa Claus – Ringo Starr

There is something wonderfully likable about Ringo Starr. He has always seemed like the kind of musician who genuinely enjoys making records and having a good time. Unfortunately, “I Wanna Be Santa Claus” sounds more like a song written for a children’s Christmas special than something from a former Beatle. The lyrics are cheerful, the arrangement is bright, and Ringo delivers the song with his familiar personality. However, that doesn’t necessarily make it a great recording. I have a hard time listening to this one without imagining Ringo dressed in a Santa suit, waving to children in a shopping mall. It is cute for a few minutes, but that’s about as far as it goes for me.

“I Wanna Be Santa Claus” was the title track of Ringo Starr’s 1999 Christmas album. Ringo wrote the song with Mark Hudson and Dick Monda, and the recording included background vocals from Jeff Lynne and Timothy B. Schmit. The album featured a mixture of original holiday songs and traditional Christmas material, including a new version of the Beatles’ “Christmas Time (Is Here Again).” Ringo was the first former Beatle to release a full-length Christmas album, which makes the project an interesting addition to his discography. Still, I would much rather hear him singing “Photograph” or “It Don’t Come Easy.” Those songs remind me why I love Ringo in the first place.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F5GzgnWHN2Q

# 9 – Cherry Cherry Christmas – Neil Diamond

Neil Diamond is one of the great American songwriters, and I have always admired his ability to create powerful melodies and unforgettable choruses. However, “Cherry Cherry Christmas” sounds a little too pleased with itself. The song takes references to some of Diamond’s most famous recordings and attempts to turn them into a holiday celebration. I understand that it is meant to be playful, but the whole thing feels like a Christmas card written to Neil Diamond fans by Neil Diamond himself. There is something strange about hearing a legendary songwriter use his own greatest hits as the foundation for a Christmas song. I love those old records, but I don’t need them recycled into holiday greetings.

Diamond wrote “Cherry Cherry Christmas” for his 2009 album A Cherry Cherry Christmas. The song incorporates references to several of his well-known compositions, including “Cherry, Cherry,” “Holly Holy,” “Red Red Wine,” and “Song Sung Blue.” The album was Diamond’s third major Christmas collection and featured both traditional holiday standards and new material. He had already established a successful history with Christmas music during the 1990s, so another seasonal release made commercial sense. Unfortunately, this particular recording comes across as a little too self-referential for my taste. Neil Diamond has written too many magnificent songs for me to get excited about one that spends so much time reminding us of the others.

# 8 – I Believe in Santa Claus – REO Speedwagon

REO Speedwagon was one of the great American rock bands of the 1970s and 1980s. The group could deliver powerful arena rock with songs like “Ridin’ the Storm Out” and “Roll with the Changes,” and it also knew how to write a successful ballad. However, “I Believe in Santa Claus” takes the softer side of the band’s music a little too far for me. The song is so sentimental that it almost sounds like something written for a Christmas greeting-card commercial. I know the message is supposed to be heartwarming, but I find the arrangement far too sweet. This is one of those records where I keep waiting for the guitars to kick in and wake everybody up.

“I Believe in Santa Claus” appeared on REO Speedwagon’s 2009 Christmas album Not So Silent Night: Christmas with REO Speedwagon. Kevin Cronin and Bruce Hall wrote the song, which became one of the group’s original contributions to the holiday music catalog. A new recording was included in the expanded 2017 edition of the album, accompanied by an official lyric video. The message focuses on holding on to the spirit and wonder of Christmas. There is nothing wrong with that sentiment, and I can understand why longtime REO Speedwagon fans might appreciate the song. Personally, I would rather hear the band turn up the amplifiers and give us a little more rock and roll.

# 7 – Jingle Bell Rock – Billy Idol

There are few things stranger than watching a musician known for his rebellious image suddenly become a Christmas entertainer. Billy Idol built his career on songs like “Rebel Yell,” “White Wedding,” and “Dancing with Myself.” Then he recorded “Jingle Bell Rock,” and suddenly the former punk rocker sounded like he was auditioning to perform at a holiday dinner party. I have always loved Billy Idol’s voice, but this performance has none of the danger or excitement that made his best records so enjoyable. The contrast between his famous sneer and the cheerful Christmas arrangement is almost impossible to take seriously. The accompanying video only adds to the entertainment.

Billy Idol recorded “Jingle Bell Rock” for his 2006 holiday album Happy Holidays, which was remixed and remastered for a 2021 reissue. The song was made famous by Bobby Helms in 1957 and has been covered by countless artists over the years. Idol’s version takes a relatively traditional approach, allowing his distinctive vocal personality to provide much of the novelty. The album also featured recordings of “White Christmas,” “Winter Wonderland,” and other holiday standards. I appreciate that Idol was willing to try something different, but this is one Christmas experiment that makes me long for the sound of Steve Stevens’ guitar and the opening chords of “Rebel Yell.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vlEX4yFq_Tc

# 6 – Red-Suited Super Man – Rod Stewart

Rod Stewart has one of the greatest voices in rock and roll history. From his work with the Faces to his remarkable solo recordings of the 1970s, he was a singer who could bring an incredible amount of personality to almost any song. Unfortunately, “Red-Suited Super Man” finds Rod moving into a style of Christmas music that sounds more like a Las Vegas holiday production than a rock and roll record. The swinging rhythm, playful lyrics, and polished arrangement are certainly cheerful, but the whole thing is a little too cute for me. I miss the Rod Stewart who could tear through a song like “Stay with Me” and make it sound as if the band might fall apart at any moment.

“Red-Suited Super Man” appeared on Stewart’s 2012 album Merry Christmas, Baby. Rod wrote the song with David Foster and Amy Foster, and the recording featured Trombone Shorty. The album marked Stewart’s first full-length Christmas collection and followed his successful series of albums devoted to standards. The song was one of the project’s original compositions, standing alongside familiar holiday favorites. Rod clearly enjoyed exploring this musical territory, and the album became a commercial success. However, I have always preferred the rougher edge of his earlier recordings. This is one Christmas song that makes me wish somebody had handed Rod an electric guitar instead of another arrangement for a holiday television special.

# 5 – Christmas Is the Time to Say I Love You – Billy Squier

I know this one is going to upset some people because “Christmas Is the Time to Say I Love You” has become a favorite among fans who grew up watching MTV in the early 1980s. I was always a fan of Billy Squier’s great rock songs, especially “The Stroke,” “In the Dark,” and “Everybody Wants You.” However, his Christmas recording sounds a little too much like a holiday promotional event for my taste. The big group chorus and cheerful atmosphere are certainly fun, but the whole thing feels like a room full of people trying to convince everybody that they are having the greatest Christmas party of all time. Sometimes that kind of enthusiasm can become exhausting.

Billy Squier released “Christmas Is the Time to Say I Love You” in 1981, during the period when his album Don’t Say No was making him a major rock star. The song became particularly well known through its music video, which featured Squier performing with a crowd of MTV employees and television personalities. It remains a wonderful piece of early MTV history, capturing the excitement of the network’s first years. Many fans treasure the recording for that reason, and I completely understand the nostalgia. Still, when it comes to Billy Squier’s music, I would much rather hear one of his great guitar-driven rock songs. This Christmas singalong just doesn’t have the same impact for me.

# 4 – Thank God It’s Christmas – Queen

How does a band capable of recording “Bohemian Rhapsody,” “Somebody to Love,” and “We Will Rock You” end up with a Christmas song as ordinary as “Thank God It’s Christmas”? That has always been my reaction to this recording. Queen was one of the most imaginative bands in rock history. They could move from hard rock to opera to beautiful ballads without sounding like anybody else. Yet their Christmas single feels surprisingly predictable. Freddie Mercury sings beautifully, of course, but the song never develops into anything particularly exciting. I keep waiting for one of those incredible Queen moments when the music suddenly goes somewhere unexpected. Unfortunately, it never really happens.

“Thank God It’s Christmas” was released as a standalone single in November 1984. Brian May and Roger Taylor wrote the song during the period surrounding Queen’s The Works album and tour. The single reached number twenty-one on the United Kingdom charts and later appeared on compilation releases. In 2019, Queen created an animated music video for the original recording, giving the song renewed attention. Brian May and Roger Taylor also revisited the track with additional instrumentation and vocals in 2026. I appreciate the sincerity of the original performance, but when I think about Queen’s remarkable catalog, this is one of the last recordings I would choose to demonstrate the band’s musical genius.

# 3 – We All Need Christmas – Def Leppard

Def Leppard is responsible for some of the greatest hard rock albums of the 1980s. Pyromania and Hysteria were filled with enormous guitar sounds, powerful hooks, and some of the most memorable choruses in rock history. Then there is “We All Need Christmas,” which sounds like somebody turned the band into a group of sentimental holiday entertainers. The gentle acoustic arrangement and heartfelt lyrics are a long way from “Photograph” and “Rock of Ages.” I understand that musicians grow older and enjoy exploring different musical styles, but this one has always struck me as painfully ordinary. It is difficult to believe that a band with such a distinctive sound could release something so anonymous.

“We All Need Christmas” was released in October 2018 and included in the campaign surrounding Def Leppard’s greatest-hits collection The Story So Far – The Best Of. Bassist Rick Savage wrote the song, while Ronan McHugh handled production. The recording was accompanied by a music video featuring the band and contributions from fans. Its message celebrates the importance of togetherness and hope during the holiday season. Those are certainly worthwhile sentiments, but I don’t think the arrangement does much to distinguish the song from countless other Christmas ballads. Def Leppard has always been capable of making even its slower songs sound enormous. This one never reaches that level for me.

# 2 – Unwrap You at Christmas – The Monkees

I have always loved the Monkees. Their television show was fantastic, and the group recorded some of the most memorable pop-rock songs of the 1960s. However, “Unwrap You at Christmas” is one of those recordings that makes me wish somebody had stepped into the studio and suggested a different idea. The title alone sounds like something from a novelty Christmas album. The song has a catchy melody, but the whole arrangement feels a little too precious for my taste. I know the Monkees were never afraid to have fun, and that was part of their charm. Still, there is a big difference between the clever humor of their early records and a Christmas song built around a gift-wrapping joke.

“Unwrap You at Christmas” appeared on the Monkees’ 2018 album Christmas Party. Andy Partridge of XTC wrote the song, and the album was produced by Adam Schlesinger. The project featured contributions from Micky Dolenz, Michael Nesmith, and Peter Tork, along with recordings featuring the late Davy Jones. It was the group’s first full-length Christmas album and included both original compositions and covers of familiar holiday songs. The album offered fans another opportunity to enjoy the Monkees’ unmistakable vocal sound, but this particular recording has never been one of my favorites. I would rather spend Christmas listening to “Daydream Believer” or “Pleasant Valley Sunday.” Those songs still make me smile every time.

# 1 – Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reggae – Paul McCartney

We close out our list of the 20 worst Christmas songs by great bands and solo artists with a recording that still leaves me shaking my head. Paul McCartney is one of the greatest songwriters who ever lived. He wrote “Yesterday,” “Hey Jude,” “Let It Be,” “Maybe I’m Amazed,” and hundreds of other remarkable compositions. So how did we end up with “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reggae”? The title sounds like a joke, and the recording doesn’t do much to change that impression. It is a strange little instrumental that attempts to combine the familiar Christmas melody with a reggae rhythm. The result sounds like something McCartney might have recorded while fooling around in the studio, never expecting anybody to hear it.

McCartney recorded “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reggae” in May 1975 at Abbey Road Studios. The instrumental was eventually released in November 1979 as the B-side of his enormously popular Christmas single “Wonderful Christmastime.” The original “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer” melody was written by Johnny Marks, while McCartney arranged the tune in his own unusual style. The recording features McCartney playing several instruments, with Bob Loveday contributing violin. It later appeared as a bonus track on expanded editions of Wings’ Back to the Egg album.

I have always admired Paul McCartney’s willingness to experiment with different musical styles. That adventurous spirit helped make the Beatles one of the greatest bands in history and contributed to so many wonderful moments during his solo career. But not every musical experiment needs to be released to the public. “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reggae” is one of those recordings that probably should have remained a private studio curiosity. It is difficult to believe that the same musician who wrote some of the most beautiful melodies in popular music thought this would make a great Christmas record. For me, that makes it the perfect choice for the number-one spot on our list.

Read More Classic Rock Articles

For more great music features, visit ClassicRockHistory.com. You can also explore our Classic Rock Bands List and Directory and our Artists’ Interviews Directory.

Updated November 22, 2026

20 Worst Christmas Songs By Great Bands And Solo Artists article published on ClassicRockHistory.com © 2026

DMCA.com Protection Status

20 Worst Christmas Songs By Great Bands And Artists
The Rascals Songs
Complete List Of The Rascals Songs From A to Z
Meat Loaf Songs
Complete List Of Meat Loaf Songs From A to Z
20 Most Beautiful Christmas Songs Of All Time
20 Most Beautiful Christmas Songs Of All Time
Doobie Brothers Albums
Top 10 Doobie Brothers Albums
Electric Light Orchestra Albums
10 Electric Light Orchestra Albums Everyone Should Own
Stevie Nicks Albums
Top 10 Stevie Nicks Albums
Favorite Tom Waits Albums
Our 10 Favorite Tom Waits Albums
Brian May Interview
Brian May of Queen: The ClassicRockHistory.com Interview
Bones Hewson Of Tailgunner Interview
An Interview With Bones Hewson Of Tailgunner
Billy Rowe Interview
An Interview With Billy Rowe Of JetBoy & Buckcherry
Laurence Juber Interview
An Interview With Laurence Juber, Formerly Of Paul McCartney & Wings
10 Unique Rock And Roll Singers That Sounded Like No One Else
10 Unique Rock And Roll Singers That Sounded Like No One Else
Artists Who Changed Their Names
9 Artists Who Changed Their Names During Their Music Careers
Alice Cooper Original Band Reunites For First Album in 51 Years
Alice Cooper Original Band Reunites For First Alice Cooper Original Band Reunited For First Album In More Than 50 Years in 51 Years
11 Classic Bands Who Returned With New Music After A Long Gap
11 Classic Bands Who Returned With New Music After A Long Gap
Taylor Swift Albums And Discography
Complete List Of Taylor Swift Albums And Discography
Three Dog Night 1968 Debut Album Review
Review Of Living in the Material World 50th Anniversary Reissue
Review Of Living in the Material World 50th Anniversary Reissue
10 Best Breakup Songs For Shattered Hearts
10 Best Breakup Songs For Shattered Hearts