Carrie Underwood Songs Ranked

Carrie Underwood Songs

Photo: Matthew Wittkopp from Annapolis, USA, CC BY 2.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0>, via Wikimedia Commons

Our Top 10 Carrie Underwood Songs list takes a look at a famous singer/songwriter/author who got her start in the music business by winning the fourth season on American Idol. She made history when her winning single “Inside Your Heaven” from the reality show debuted at number one on the Hot 100 charts. She made history because she was the first country artist to accomplish this feat. She is also the only country singer in the 2000s era to have a number one song on the Hot 100 charts.

Carrie Underwood was born Carrie Marie Underwood on March 10, 1983. When she was 14, she tried to audition for Capitol Records, but it didn’t work out. The contract was canceled after the company’s management changed. It’s a good thing the contract didn’t work out because she wouldn’t have auditioned for American Idol. She auditioned for the show and went on to win the competition in 2005. The rest was history. She could have easily been a flash in the pan because of the way she got her start, but she showed that a really star could have a successful career.

She released her debut album Some Hearts in 2005. It was one of the best selling albums in 2006 in all genres. The album was one of the best selling country albums in 2007. She was the first female singer to get this honor back to back for a country album. The album was number one on the country charts and number two on Billboard 200. The album sold an impressive 315,000 copies in its first week. It features the number one hit singles “Jesus, Take The Wheel,” “Some Hearts,” “Don’t Forget to Remember Me,” “Before He Cheats,” “Wasted” and “Inside Your Heaven.” The album sold over 7 million copies. She won numerous awards for this album.

She had big shoes to fill when she released her second album because of the success of her debut album. In 2007, she released her second album Carnival Ride, which debuted at number one on the country and Billboard 200 charts. The album sold a whopping 527,000 copies in its first week. The album went double platinum after only two months on the charts. It features the hit singles “So Small,” “All-American Girl,” “Last Name,” “Just a Dream” and “I Told You So.” The album sold over four million copies. She won numerous awards for this project as well.

She released her third album Play On in 2009. It debuted at number one on the charts. It sold over 318,000 copies in its first week. It features the singles “Cowboy Casanova,” “Temporary Home,” “Undo It” and “Mama’s Song.” The album sold over three million copies. She won awards for this project.

Carrie Underwood released her fourth album Blown Away in 2012. The album debuted at number one on the charts. It sold over 267,000 copies in its first week. It features the hit singles “Good Girl,” “Blown Away,” “Two Black Cadillacs” and “See You Again.” The album sold over three million copies.

She released a greatest hits album called Greatest Hits: Decade #1 in 2014. It features her greatest hit songs plus two new songs. It features the number one single “Something in the Water.” It also features the single “Little Toy Guns.” The album sold over one million copies.

Carrie Underwood released her fifth album Storyteller in 2015. It debuted at number one on the country charts and number two on the Billboard 200 charts. This album made her the first country artist to have five albums debut at number one or two on the charts. It features the singles “Smoke Break,” “Heartbeat,” “Church Bells” and “Dirty Laundry.” The album sold over 164,000 in its first week and went on to sell over one million copies. She won multiple awards for this album.

Carrie Underwood released her sixth album Cry Pretty in 2018. It debuted at number one on the Billboard 200 charts. It features the singles “Cry Pretty,” “Love Wins,” “Southbound” and “Drinking Alone.” The album sold over 500,000 copies.

She released a Christmas album called My Gift in 2020. It features traditional Christmas songs. The album debuted at number eight on Billboard 200 and number one on the country charts. It sold 43,000 copies in its first week. It features the singles “Favorite Time of Year” and “Hallelujah.”

Carrie Underwood released her eighth album My Savior in 2021. This is a gospel cover album. It features traditional gospel songs. It debuted at number one on the country and Christian charts and number four on the Billboard 200.

Carrie Underwood has an impressive body of work. She showed that she could be a star despite being on a reality show. Most of the contestants from American Idol disappeared from the music scene or didn’t become big stars. Underwood is the exception to the rule. She went on to become one of the most successful country artists of all time. This list was hard to compile because she has a lot of hit singles. This Top 10 Carrie Underwood Songs list will feature just some of her hit singles.

Top 10 Carrie Underwood Songs Ranked

#10 – Good Girl

The first song on our Top 10 Carrie Underwood Songs list is the sleek and soulful “Good Girl” from the Blown Away album. This up-tempo song has a country and rock sound. This cautionary tale is about warning her friend that her boyfriend is no good for her. This is a relatable song because females usually warn their friends when they are better off without their exes. You will be hooked when the guitar riffs begin. The music doesn’t sound like your typical country song. It has a rock edge. It also has a catchy dance beat. It’s excellent for fans of all genres. The guitar riffs are on fire. The guitar solo sells the music. The hook is infectious and commands you to sing along with her. She has a lot of energy throughout the song. She vocally soars in the bridge and the hook. She holds amazing notes considering it’s an up-tempo song.

# 9 – Two Black Cadillacs

The next song on our Top 10 Carrie Underwood Songs list is the feisty “Two Black Cadillacs” from the Blown Away album. This song has a country and pop sound. This is a vengeful song about two women who find out that they are seeing the same man. The women decide to kill him. This is a unique story that you usually see in a movie. People don’t usually sing songs about killing the cheater in a relationship. This track has crossover appeal because it will please country, pop and rock fans.

The instrumentation is amazing. The guitar riffs and drumbeats are the ultimate marriage. The guitar riffs will allow you to play air guitar. There is a somber piano solo in the bridge that adds to the vengefulness of the song. Underwood’s vocals are outstanding. She shows her versatility in this song through the lyrics as well as the vocals. She shows such incredible range that she could be up there with the other power balladeers. She sounds similar to Christina Aguilera in this song.

# 8 – Cowboy Casanova

This thematic song is from the Play On album. This song has a country and rock sound. This song is a warning to women about men who are wolves in sheep’s clothing. This isn’t a male bashing song. It’s simply about letting women know about these kind of men. This track gives Underwood a chance to show off her sassy side. She shows that her vocals are not just suitable for ballads. She can sing up-tempo songs as well. She sings the verses with such rapid control and preciseness. She sings the hook infectiously. She doesn’t hold back when she sings the powerful hook. She projects throughout the hook. She doesn’t hold long notes, but she does belt the lyrics. Some of the lyrics are a little hard to understand, but it doesn’t take away from how good the song is.

# 7 – All-American Girl

This unique song is from the Carnival Ride album. This song has a country and pop sound. This is a charming song about a man falling for an all American girl at different stages of her life. This song is told in parts. The first verse is about a father hoping for a boy, but getting a girl. In the second verse, she falls in love with a football player. In the third verse, she marries the boy and has a child of her own. This song is part of Underwood’s life story because she ended up marrying an athlete. The music has a traditional country sound, but it also has something for rock and pop fans. The electric guitar gives the song a rock edge. The fiddle and banjo give the song the country sound. This song is appropriate for her image because she has a good girl image. Underwood’s vocals are pristine and pure. She holds impressive notes towards the end of the song.

# 6 – Wasted

This therapeutic song is from the Some Hearts album. It has a country and pop sound. This is a cathartic song about addiction. The addiction is told in two parts. One part is about being addicted to a toxic relationship while the other part is about being addicted to alcoholism. This is a different song for Underwood because it doesn’t fit her good girl image. It shows that she can sing about a variety of subjects and sound convincing doing it. She pulls back vocally in the verses and lets loose in the hook. She sounds strong and powerful in the hook. She holds a big note while her vocals soar in the fadeout. The music is sobering and soothing. In the verses, the music is soft while it gets louder in the hook. The soft music gives the listener a chance to focus on Underwood’s incredible vocals.

# 5 – Don’t Forget To Remember Me

The next song on our Top 10 Carrie Underwood Songs list is the emotional “Don’t Forget To Remember Me” from the Some Hearts album. This song has a country sound. This is a touching song about a love between a mother and daughter. The daughter is preparing to leave home after graduating. The mother doesn’t want her to forget about her. This is a different kind of love song. It’s not a romantic song. It’s a song about a love between a mother and child. It’s a relatable topic because most parents and children go through this during graduation time.

This is the type of song that you would expect from Underwood based on her image. The lyrics of the song will have you thinking about your own parents especially if you’re close to them. It will teach you to appreciate your parents while they are still here. This sounds like a traditional country song mixed with a soft rock sound. Underwood’s vocals are subdued in the verses, but are powerful and strong in the hook. It’s impossible not to become emotional while listening to this moving song.

# 4 – Blown Away

This vengeful song is from the album of the same name. This up-tempo song has a pop and rock sound. This is an antagonistic song about a girl locking herself in the basement while her alcoholic father is passed out on the couch. Here is some trivia about the song. This song was inspired by 80’s music. The music does have an 80’s rock sound to it. This song gave Underwood a chance to break away from country music and venture into pop rock.

The somber production along with her soaring vocals creates a musical classic. The synthesizers, strings and guitars create a perfect sound for Underwood. Underwood displays her hollow vocals in the hook. It sounds as if she has an echo. It was a creative way for her to have a double in the song. She sounds like Christina Aguilera in this song. She even does her vocal tics. Lyrically, this song is nothing you would hear on the radio. People don’t sing subjects like this, but Underwood took the chance and it worked for her.

# 3 – Jesus, Take The Wheel

This cathartic song is from the Some Hearts album. This ballad has country and Christian sound. This is a comforting song about surrendering to a higher power. This song has become synonymous with losing a loved one. This song could have been a risk for Underwood to sing because of the melancholy theme. Critics weren’t sure if this song would have been a hit. The critics were wrong because it ended up being one of her biggest hit singles. It has crossover appeal because fans of all genres can appreciate the message in the song.

Underwood’s vocals are sentimental and convincing. This song showcases how strong her voice is while tackling difficult vocal runs. She is a novice here, but she sounds as if she has been singing for years. She vocally explodes in the final chorus when she belts and holds notes. Everything about this song works. Her vocals are amazing and the music is fantastic.

# 2 – Inside Your Heaven

This romantic song is from the Some Hearts album. This has a country and pop sound. This is a love song about the person she loves. This is the song she sang on American Idol when she won the competition. This is a beautiful love song. Underwood has the voice of an angel. It’s no wonder she won the competition. She sounds amazing. It’s hard to believe that she wasn’t a professional when she sang this song. She sounds like a seasoned vet. She is doing everything right vocally in this song. She has incredible control when it comes to holding notes and belting. She starts the song off softly and then vocally explodes in the hook. The music is arranged perfectly to match her outstanding vocals. The music starts softly and the verses and gets louder in the hook. This song is flawless and could have easily been number one on this list.

# 1 – Before He Cheats

We have come to the number one song on our Top 10 Carrie Underwood Songs list. The number one song is “Before He Cheats” from the Some Hearts album. It should come as no surprise that this fierce song is number one. This song has a country sound. This is a sassy song about her getting revenge on a man who cheated on her. This anti-cheating anthem explains what she’s willing to do to her cheating boyfriend. This is something that most women would probably want to do if their men cheat on them. This song is definitely for females.

Men can probably relate to the song as well, but they wouldn’t be able to pull off the antics Carrie Underwood mentions throughout the song. The irony is two men wrote this song for Carrie Underwood. This is one of the best revenge songs out there. She sings the song so passionately as if it’s to someone in particular. This song gives Carrie Underwood a chance to show off her feisty side. She got a break from her good girl image. She sings this with a grit that she doesn’t use in too many songs. She belts and holds magnificent notes throughout the song. This song is flawless and deserves to be number one on this list.

Carrie Underwood Songs Ranked article published on Classic RockHistory.com© 2021

Classicrockhistory.com claims ownership of all its original content and Intellectual property under United States Copyright laws and those of all other foreign countries. No one person, business or any organizations is allowed to republish any of our original content anywhere on the web or in print without our permission. 

DMCA.com Protection Status

Add Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Spanky & Our Gang Songs
Top 10 Spanky & Our Gang Songs
Celtic Frost Songs
Top 10 Celtic Frost Songs
10 Things You Didn't Know About Bruce Springsteen
10 Things You Didn’t Know About Bruce Springsteen
Eddie Money Cover Songs
Top 10 Eddie Money Cover Songs
Pearl Jam Albums
Top 10 Pearl Jam Albums
Velvet Underground Albums
Velvet Underground Albums Ranked
The Kinks Albums
Top 10 Kinks Albums
John Prine Albums
Top 10 John Prine Albums
Vanilla Fudge New Release
Vanilla Fudge Releases Retro New Single In Tribute To Tim Bogert
Metallica Surprise Concerts
Metallica Continues Their Round Of Surprise Theater Concerts
Tori Amos New Album Ocean To Ocean
Tori Amos Announces New Album Ocean To Ocean Due 10/29/21
Becoming Led Zeppelin
Becoming Led Zeppelin: 1st Authorized Led Zeppelin Documentary