The Lumineers built one of the most successful folk-rock careers of the 21st century through heartfelt songwriting, memorable melodies, and an evolving lineup of talented musicians. This complete guide explores every current and former member who helped shape the band’s sound from its New Jersey beginnings to worldwide success.
Feature Photo: MPH Photos / Shutterstock.com
The Lumineers was formed in 2005 in Ramsey, New Jersey. Initially started by Wesley Schultz (vocals and guitar) and Jeremiah Fraites (drums and percussion), they later moved to Denver, Colorado, and expanded their lineup. Their self-titled debut album, released in 2012, propelled them into the spotlight, buoyed by the hit single “Ho Hey,” which not only received extensive radio play but also featured in multiple commercials and TV shows, helping it climb to the top of the music charts. Following their debut, the band released three more albums: Cleopatra in 2016, III in 2019, and Brightside in 2022. Each album has contributed to solidifying their presence in the indie music scene, with Cleopatra debuting at number one on the US Billboard 200. The band’s music has earned them several awards and nominations, highlighting their significant impact on the folk-rock genre.
Wesley Schultz
Wesley Schultz, a founding member of The Lumineers, has served as the lead vocalist and guitarist since the band’s inception in 2005. Before forming The Lumineers, Schultz performed with Jeremiah Fraites, who would also become a founding member, in the New York City music scene. Their decision to relocate to Denver marked a new beginning for the duo, where they met cellist Neyla Pekarek. Schultz has played a critical role in writing and composing the majority of the band’s music, contributing significantly to all four studio albums. His distinct voice and storytelling are pivotal to the band’s sound and success. Outside of The Lumineers, Schultz released a solo album in 2020 titled Vignettes, showcasing his versatility and depth as a musician by covering songs that have influenced his artistic journey.
Jeremiah Fraites
Jeremiah Fraites co-founded The Lumineers with Wesley Schultz and has been the band’s drummer and pianist. Like Schultz, he was heavily involved in the early music-making process that defined their distinctive style. His contributions extend beyond the drums; he plays piano and other instruments, offering rich layers to the band’s music that have been evident across all their albums. Fraites’ ability to blend traditional rock instruments with more classical ones helps create the folk-rock sound for which the band is known. In 2021, Fraites released his own solo album, Piano Piano, which comprises instrumental piano compositions and highlights his musical talents beyond the band’s work.
Neyla Pekarek
Neyla Pekarek joined The Lumineers in 2010 after answering a Craigslist ad posted by Schultz and Fraites. Her skills as a cellist added a new dimension to the band’s sound, contributing to their debut album and Cleopatra. Pekarek’s cello played a fundamental role in the orchestration of many tracks, enriching the band’s melody lines and harmonic structures. In 2018, she decided to leave The Lumineers to pursue a solo career. Her debut solo album, Rattlesnake, was released in 2019 and tells the story of Rattlesnake Kate, a figure from Colorado folklore, further showcasing her inclination toward narrative-rich compositions.
Maxwell Hughes
Maxwell Hughes briefly joined The Lumineers prior to the release of their first album. As a skilled guitarist, Hughes contributed to the early development of the band’s sound, although he was not part of any major recordings that made it onto the debut album. After departing from the band, Hughes continued his career as a solo artist, emphasizing his virtuoso guitar skills. He has also received accolades for his acoustic work, including being a finalist in the International Fingerstyle Guitar Championship.
Ben Wahamaki
Ben Wahamaki was part of The Lumineers during their early years, playing bass during the tours that followed their debut album’s release. His tenure with the band was short-lived, and he left after touring with them for a couple of years. Following his time with The Lumineers, Wahamaki has maintained a relatively low profile in the music industry.
Jay Van Dyke
Jay Van Dyke played with The Lumineers during the band’s formative years before they achieved mainstream success. His contributions came primarily during live performances rather than studio recordings. After his departure, Van Dyke continued pursuing music through various projects while exploring different musical styles.
Updated July 13, 2026
For more on The Lumineers, check out our Top 10 Songs from The Lumineers article, or explore their catalog further with our Complete List of The Lumineers Albums and Discography and Complete List of The Lumineers Songs from A to Z.
If you enjoy that stomping, folk-driven sound, check out our coverage of Mumford & Sons and Fleet Foxes, two other bands that helped define that same folk revival era.
Complete List Of Lumineers Band Members article published on ClassicRockHistory.com© 2026
