Complete List Of MercyMe Band Members

Feature Photo: Toa Nidhiki05, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons

From their formation in a small abandoned daycare center in Greenville, Texas, to becoming one of the most successful contemporary Christian music acts of the past three decades, MercyMe built their career on authenticity and emotional honesty. Founded in 1994 by lead vocalist Bart Millard, guitarist Michael Scheuchzer, and keyboardist James Bryson, the band released six independent albums before signing with INO Records in 2001. Their major-label debut, Almost There, achieved triple platinum certification largely due to the phenomenal success of the single “I Can Only Imagine,” which became the best-selling Christian single of all time.

Since that breakthrough moment, MercyMe has established itself as a dominant force in Christian music with twelve studio albums, numerous gold and platinum certifications, thirteen consecutive top-five singles on the Billboard Christian Songs chart, and multiple Grammy nominations. The band has won eight Dove Awards and achieved numerous other accolades throughout their career. While the original trio formed the backbone of the group, the addition of bassist Nathan Cochran and percussionist Robby Shaffer in the late 1990s solidified the rhythm section that would define their sound. Guitarist Barry Graul joined in 2003, providing additional depth to their arrangements. The band’s stable current lineup has remained consistent since 2014, when founding keyboardist Jim Bryson retired from performing, leaving only Millard and Scheuchzer as the original members still active.

MercyMe’s catalog spans multiple genres within contemporary Christian music, blending pop, rock, and worship elements while exploring themes of faith, redemption, family, and personal testimony. Their discography includes Spoken For, Undone, Coming Up to Breathe, All That Is Within Me, The Generous Mr. Lovewell, The Hurt & the Healer, Welcome to the New, Lifer, Inhale (Exhale), Always Only Jesus, and their latest release Wonder & Awe. Beyond their music, the band’s story was adapted into a major motion picture in 2018, with a sequel scheduled for release in 2026. The group has performed extensively across North America, performed at the National Football League, and conducted charitable tours with various organizations to support causes ranging from diabetes research to international relief efforts.

Bart Millard

Bart Marshall Millard was born on December 1, 1972, and serves as the lead vocalist and primary songwriter for MercyMe. He founded the band in 1994 after moving to Oklahoma City with James Bryson following a trip to Europe, where both felt called to pursue full-time music ministry. Millard has been with the band since 1994, contributing vocals and songwriting to all studio albums and independent releases. His vocal presence defines the band’s signature sound, delivering the emotive delivery that became the hallmark of tracks like “I Can Only Imagine,” “Word of God Speak,” “Here With Me,” “Spoken For,” and “All of Creation.”

Millard’s songwriting emerged from deeply personal experiences, particularly the death of his father from pancreatic cancer in 1991. This loss profoundly influenced his lyrics, particularly on the landmark single “I Can Only Imagine,” which he wrote in 1998 for the band’s independent album The Worship Project before it became the centerpiece of Almost There. The song earned Millard the Dove Award for Song of the Year in 2002 and established him as a songwriter capable of translating personal grief into universal messages of faith and hope. Beyond his work with MercyMe, Millard released two solo albums: Hymned, No. 1 in 2005 and Hymned Again in 2008. Hymned, No. 1 was ranked No. 9 on Christianity Today’s Best Christian Albums of 2005, and Millard himself was deemed Best Male Vocalist by the publication that year. Hymned Again earned him a Grammy nomination in the category of Best Southern, Country, or Bluegrass Gospel Album.

The most significant career milestone outside the band came in 2018, when his life story was adapted into the major motion picture I Can Only Imagine, directed by the Erwin Brothers. The film grossed $86 million worldwide on a $7 million production budget, making it the fifth-highest-grossing music biopic of all time. The success of the movie introduced Millard’s story to audiences far beyond the Christian music community and led to a follow-up film currently in development, scheduled for release in February 2026. Millard has also authored a memoir titled I Can Only Imagine: A Memoir, which provides deeper context into his personal journey and the creation of the band’s most iconic song. He resides in Greenville, Texas, with his wife Shannon and their five children.

Michael John Scheuchzer

Michael John Scheuchzer was born on June 8, 1975, in Portland, Maine, and has served as guitarist, keyboardist, and backing vocalist for MercyMe since the band’s formation in 1994. He is one of only two original members still active with the group. Scheuchzer met Bart Millard in Florida after Millard’s youth pastor invited him to work with a church worship band. Both men felt called to pursue full-time music ministry, and when they moved to Oklahoma City, Scheuchzer joined them as the third member of what would become MercyMe. He has contributed to every studio album and independent release, playing guitars, keyboards, and providing background vocals that enhance the band’s harmonic arrangements.

Throughout MercyMe’s discography, Scheuchzer’s instrumental contributions appear on all major releases including Almost There, Spoken For, Undone, The Christmas Sessions, Coming Up to Breathe, All That Is Within Me, The Generous Mr. Lovewell, The Hurt & the Healer, Welcome to the New, Lifer, Inhale (Exhale), Always Only Jesus, and Wonder & Awe. His guitar work and keyboard arrangements helped define the band’s evolving sound, from the rock-oriented approach of their independent albums to the more polished pop-rock production of their major-label releases. He contributed to the writing and production aspects of numerous tracks and worked closely with external producers to develop the sonic identity of later albums.

Beyond his full-time role with MercyMe, Scheuchzer has remained involved in various musical projects and community endeavors. He was involved in a tour bus accident in August 2009 when an oncoming vehicle turned left on red at an intersection in Fort Wayne, Indiana, resulting in injuries to band members and casualties to the other vehicle’s occupants. Scheuchzer survived the accident and continued performing with the band. In recent years, he has been featured in behind-the-scenes content showcasing the band’s creative process and recording sessions. He has a wife named Abby and resides in Nashville, Tennessee, where most MercyMe band members are now based.

Barry Graul

Barry Graul was born on May 18, 1961, in Baltimore, Maryland, and joined MercyMe as a second guitarist in 2003. Before joining the band, Graul had an extensive career as a session and touring guitarist, having performed with nearly twenty different artists across multiple genres. His previous credits included significant tenures with the Christian hard rock band Whitecross, where he established himself as a talented rock guitarist, and with the contemporary Christian act DC Talk, where he served as one of the band’s guitarists. Graul also performed with artists including TobyMac, Tait, Audio Adrenaline, Phil Joel, Whiteheart, and Michael Sweet, accumulating 18 years of professional experience before becoming a full-time MercyMe member.

Graul’s arrival in 2003 coincided with the development of Undone, MercyMe’s third studio album, which benefited from the expanded instrumental palette his second guitar provided. His rock-influenced style complemented Michael Scheuchzer’s more melodic approach, allowing the band to achieve greater depth in their arrangements. Graul has appeared on all MercyMe albums released since his joining: Undone, The Christmas Sessions, Coming Up to Breathe, All That Is Within Me, The Generous Mr. Lovewell, The Hurt & the Healer, Welcome to the New, Lifer, Inhale (Exhale), Always Only Jesus, and Wonder & Awe. His contributions extended beyond guitar playing to include backing vocals and songwriting assistance on various tracks. The band’s 2003 Dove Awards ceremony recognized his impact, and he subsequently received multiple Dove Awards and three ASCAP writer awards for his work with MercyMe.

Outside of his MercyMe responsibilities, Graul has maintained an interest in guitar tone and equipment, becoming known among the band’s crew for his expertise with effects pedals and amplification. He was interviewed extensively during the band’s 2017 Texas Takeover Tour regarding his gear setup and musical influences. Graul has discussed his musical journey in various interviews, noting that he joined MercyMe after watching the band perform night after night on a tour where he was originally performing for another artist. The experience of witnessing the band’s authentic worship and connection with audiences inspired him to request membership when the opportunity arose. He is married with children and resides in the Nashville area.

Nathan Cochran

Nathan Cochran joined MercyMe as bassist in 1998. He was born in Columbia, Missouri, and came from a family with strong faith connections, as his parents served as pastors. Unlike keyboardist Jim Bryson and guitarist Michael Scheuchzer, who came to music through immediate inspiration, Cochran described himself as having “stumbled into” music, influenced by his parents’ emphasis on faith and eventually finding that his relationship with Christ became the driving force behind his songwriting and performance. He was nineteen years old when he joined MercyMe, beginning what would become a twenty-plus year tenure with the band.

Cochran has served as bassist and backing vocalist on all MercyMe studio albums from the band’s major-label debut onwards, including Almost There, Spoken For, Undone, The Christmas Sessions, Coming Up to Breathe, All That Is Within Me, The Generous Mr. Lovewell, The Hurt & the Healer, Welcome to the New, Lifer, Inhale (Exhale), Always Only Jesus, and Wonder & Awe. His bass lines provide the foundational rhythmic structure that supports the band’s melodies and arrangements. Beyond his performance duties, Cochran has handled key business and production matters for the band, contributing to the organization’s overall administration and creative direction. He has appeared in various band documentaries and interviews, discussing the band’s early years of struggling to pay electric bills while building their career by performing at youth camps and summer conferences.

In his personal life, Cochran has developed interests beyond music, including archery, which he has pursued during the band’s periodic breaks from touring. His parents’ pastoral background influenced his own approach to faith and spirituality. However, he has emphasized the importance of holding individual band members accountable to their spouses and to each other as brothers rather than placing anyone on a pedestal. He has spoken candidly about the challenges of extensive touring and the importance of family support in maintaining longevity in the music industry. Cochran resides in Nashville, Tennessee, where he has been based with other band members for many years.

Robin Troy “Robby” Shaffer

Robin Troy “Robby” Shaffer joined MercyMe as drummer and percussionist in 1997, completing the core rhythm section alongside bassist Nathan Cochran. Shaffer brought a background in church worship music to the group’s early performances and developed a steady, reliable approach to rhythm that has supported the band’s high-energy live shows for over three decades. He was introduced to the band by Trent Austin, the previous drummer, and made an immediate impact that led to his continued tenure from 1997 through the present. His drumming provided the stable foundation upon which the band’s early independent albums were built and continued through their transition to major-label success.

Shaffer appears as percussionist and drummer on all MercyMe albums from Spoken For forward, contributing his drumming to tracks on Almost There, Spoken For, Undone, The Christmas Sessions, Coming Up to Breathe, All That Is Within Me, The Generous Mr. Lovewell, The Hurt & the Healer, Welcome to the New, Lifer, Inhale (Exhale), Always Only Jesus, and Wonder & Awe. His work on signature tracks like “I Can Only Imagine” and “Word of God Speak” provided the percussive backbone that allowed these songs to resonate with audiences. His steady playing style remained consistent throughout the band’s evolution from rock-oriented independent albums to the more polished contemporary Christian sound of their major releases. He was involved in the August 2009 tour bus accident but continued performing with the band after recovery.

Outside of his musical career, Shaffer has developed a family life that includes a wife and children, and he has spoken about the importance of travel and spiritual renewal in maintaining balance with the demands of extensive touring. In interviews, he described family vacations as “life-giving necessities” and mentioned traveling to international destinations like Rome and Venice for significant anniversaries. He has participated in the band’s MercyMe at Sea cruise experiences, which allow fans and band members to connect in a more relaxed setting. Shaffer resides in Nashville, Tennessee, and continues to perform with MercyMe while maintaining his commitment to the band’s worship-oriented approach to music.

James Phillip “Jim” Bryson

James Phillip Bryson, known as Jim Bryson, served as keyboardist and founding member of MercyMe from 1994 to 2014, a tenure of twenty years. Bryson met Bart Millard in Lakeland, Florida, through an invitation from Millard’s youth pastor, and the two led a church youth praise team together on a trip to Europe. Both felt called to pursue full-time music ministry, and they moved to Oklahoma City where they met Michael Scheuchzer, forming the original MercyMe trio. Bryson’s piano and keyboard arrangements formed an essential part of the band’s signature sound, particularly on their early independent albums and the crucial debut major-label album Almost There.

Bryson’s keyboard contributions appear throughout MercyMe’s discography, including all independent albums and studio albums through 2014. On major-label releases, he played keyboards on Almost There, providing the piano introduction to “I Can Only Imagine” that became one of the most recognizable elements of the song. His work continued on Spoken For, Undone, The Christmas Sessions, Coming Up to Breathe, All That Is Within Me, The Generous Mr. Lovewell, The Hurt & the Healer, and Welcome to the New. Bryson’s arrangement sensibilities helped define the band’s aesthetic during their formative years and their rise to prominence in contemporary Christian music. He was present during the August 2009 tour bus accident but survived and continued with the band.

In 2014, following the release of Welcome to the New, Bryson made the decision to retire from MercyMe, ending his twenty-year association with the band. His departure meant that only Bart Millard and Michael Scheuchzer remained as original members still actively performing with the group. Since his retirement from the band, limited public information has emerged about Bryson’s post-MercyMe career activities, though he remains recognized as a foundational figure in the band’s sound during their most crucial development period.

David Cowan

David Cowan served as drummer for MercyMe from 1994 to 1995, handling percussion duties during the band’s earliest formation period. Very limited documentation exists regarding Cowan’s tenure with the group, as he departed during the band’s initial years before they achieved any mainstream recognition. He played on the band’s first independent releases during their earliest phase of development when they were still based in Oklahoma and performing locally at youth conferences and church events. Cowan left the group in 1995, after which Trent Austin took over drumming responsibilities for the next two years.

Trent Austin

Trent Austin, an Oklahoma native, served as drummer for MercyMe from 1995 to 1997. He played on the band’s first two independent albums, Pleased to Meet You (released in 1995) and Traces of Rain (released in 1997), both of which were produced on limited budgets and distributed primarily through live performances and local Christian networks. During his tenure, the band was developing their early rock-oriented sound and experimenting with worship and pop-rock arrangements. Austin was instrumental in introducing Robby Shaffer to MercyMe, effectively facilitating the transition to the drummer who would define the band’s percussive sound for the next three decades. Austin departed in 1997, marking the end of his involvement with the group as the band prepared for more ambitious touring and recording efforts.

Kendall Combes

Kendall Combes served as bassist and backing vocalist for MercyMe from 1994 to 1998, providing foundational rhythm during the band’s earliest years. He appeared on the same independent albums as Trent Austin, contributing to Pleased to Meet You, Traces of Rain, and other early releases. Combes’ bass lines supported the band’s rock-influenced sound during their pre-major label era, and his backing vocals appeared on various tracks throughout those early independent projects. He departed the band in 1998 as MercyMe was preparing for their major-label debut, coinciding with Nathan Cochran’s arrival as the new bassist. Combes’ contributions were essential to establishing the rhythm section foundation during the band’s formative years.

Jim Richmond

Jim Richmond served as guitarist for MercyMe from 1994 to 1995, making him one of the earliest musicians to work with the band. During his brief tenure, Richmond played on the band’s initial recordings and local performances before departing to pursue other opportunities. Very little detailed information is publicly available about Richmond’s contributions or subsequent career, though his work represents part of the band’s earliest experimental phase when they were still determining their musical direction and sound.

Check out more MercyMe articles on ClassicRockHistory.com Just click on any of the links below……

Top 10 MercyMe Songs

Classicrockhistory.com claims ownership of all its original content and Intellectual property under United States Copyright laws and those of all other foreign countries. No one person, business, or organization is allowed to re-publish any of our original content anywhere on the web or in print without our permission. All photos used are either public domain Creative Commons photos or licensed officially from Shutterstock under license with ClassicRockHistory.com. All photo credits have been placed at the end of the article. Album Cover Photos are affiliate links and the property of Amazon and are stored on the Amazon server. Any theft of our content will be met with swift legal action against the infringing websites.