9 Bands That Never Replaced Departed Members

Photo: SolarScott / CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0)

The standard practice when a successful band loses a member for any of the usual reasons (quit, fired, or depends on who you ask) is to replace them. Bands typically don’t want to mess with the three-, four- or five-piece dynamic they’ve established, plus they often see new members as an opportunity to infuse fresh musical ideas into the band’s sound. However, in a few cases, bands never officially fill those places. This may be because new members always tend to be divisive with fans or because they want to avoid a too-many-cooks-in-the-kitchen scenario (which may have caused the split with the last guy). When bands do opt for this, usually either a remaining member will end up performing double-duty, or the “new” players are viewed as sidemen or women and not made a full-fledged member of the line-up (or both). Here are nine bands who elected not to replace departed members officially and how each of them compensated for the absence.

#9 – Sleater-Kinney

Probably the most successful and influential band to come out of the Olympia, Washington riot grrrl movement of the Nineties, Sleater-Kinney has always been fronted by two singer/guitarists, Corin Tucker and Carrie Brownstein. Since 1996, the trio had been rounded out by drummer Janet Weiss for both of its eras (the band broke up in 2006 but reunited in 2014). In mid-2019 Weiss announced that she was leaving the band, and later that year she explained that she felt that despite her solid history with them, Sleater-Kinney had essentially become a partnership between Tucker and Brownstein, and that her role had been diminished to that of a side person (this may explain why touring replacement Angie Boylan was not made a full member, with Sleater-Kinney now officially a duo).

#8 – R.E.M.

After a slow and steady rise from cult- to platinum status in the Eighties, the first half of the Nineties proved to be just as much of a victory for Athens, Georgia rockers R.E.M. However, in 1995 longtime drummer Bill Berry collapsed onstage during a show due to what turned out to be a brain aneurysm. Although he survived and eventually got back behind the drum kit, two years later he would make his departure from R.E.M., largely stepping away from music and opting to become a farmer instead. R.E.M. continued as a trio, with a number of drummers (including Joey Waronker and Bill Rieflin) filling in for Berry both in the studio and on tour, before disbanding in 2011.

#7 – Foreigner

Seminal AOR rockers Foreigner debuted in 1977 as a six-piece band and scored a Top 5 multi-platinum album with each of their first three releases. Although they had clearly assembled a winning team, in 1980 guitarist Ian McDonald and keyboardist Al Greenwood were both fired, the reason seemingly being that lead guitarist Mick Jones sought more control over the band’s sound. Jones and the other remaining members continued Foreigner as a four-piece (and it seems the departed members weren’t missed much, since their next release in 1981, 4, became the band’s first number one album in the U.S.)

#6 – Supertramp

British prog/pop outfit Supertramp closed out the Seventies with their biggest album, Breakfast in America. However, guitarist Roger Hodgson – whose falsetto lead vocals on hits like “Dreamer” and “The Logical Song” had become synonymous with their sound – grew increasingly disenfranchised in the aftermath, and publicly announced that the next album and tour would be his final go-round with the band. The title …Famous Last Words… seemed to indicate that Supertramp was packing it in, but they resurfaced three years later with keyboardist Rick Davies now handling all of the lead vocals and writing. For the 1985 album Brother Where You Bound, Supertramp also declined to add another full-time guitarist to the line-up, instead relying on several session players, including David Gilmour of Pink Floyd.

#5 – The Doors

In 1971 after Jim Morrison went to live in Paris, the other three members were already working on the next album without him when the legendary frontman was found dead at age 27 that summer. It’s still a bit unclear whether or not the Doors actually did ask a young James Newell Osterberg Jr. – better known as Iggy Pop – to replace Morrison (and if he declined the offer), but the appropriately titled Other Voices (1971) as well as the follow-up Full Circle (1972) would both feature surviving members Ray Manzarek and Robby Krieger sharing lead vocals. However, the post-Morrison period of The Doors would quickly become little more than a footnote in the band’s legacy.

#4 – The J. Geils Band

The wait was long but the payoff was huge for the J. Geils Band, who after more than a decade of mostly minor hits scored a number one album in 1982 entitled Freeze Frame fueled by the massive hit single called “Centerfold.” With the band now “starting over on top” (as Rolling Stone phrased it), they shocked everyone the following year with the announcement that longtime frontman Peter Wolf – who had become their public face – was no longer in the band.

Keyboardist Seth Justman and drummer Stephen Jo Bladd took over lead vocals for You’re Gettin’ Even While I’m Gettin’ Odd (1984), but the odds were clearly not in their favor as the album ended up as the band’s lowest-charting since their 1970 debut and ultimately became their final (and only non-Wolf) full-length studio release. Wolf – whose solo career began promisingly but then also faltered commercially – would rejoin the band starting in 1999.

#3 – The Rolling Stones

By the mid-Seventies, The Rolling Stones had already established a legacy in rock history rivaled only by The Beatles. However, the band had to endure two major shake-ups in their roster. The upheavals the band experienced were defined by the replacements of guitarist Brian Jones by Mick Taylor in 1969, and then Taylor being replaced himself by Ronnie Wood in 1975. However, the Stones opted for a different approach after another founding member, bassist Bill Wyman, announced his departure from the band in 1993.

After three decades, rock’s all-time most famous five-piece rock band became a quartet, at least in terms of official members. Darryl Jones, who had previously played with Eric Clapton, Sting and Patti LaBelle among many others, has very skillfully handled duties on bass in the band starting on the 1994 studio album Voodoo Lounge (so let’s start the inevitable debate: should Jones have been made a full-fledged member of the Stones?).

Since Charlie Watts’s death in 2021, The Rolling Stones have had Steve Jordan handling the drum chair. However, like Darryl Jones, Steve Jordan has not become an official Rolling Stone. The band is now down to just three official members in Mick Jagger, Keith Richards and Ronnie Wood.

#2 – Genesis

This band could almost be counted for the list twice… Following Peter Gabriel’s departure in 1975, Genesis had intended to find a new frontman, and thus combed through hundreds of demos and held numerous auditions. They got as far as the recording studio with another lead singer. Still, it was ultimately decided that drummer Phil Collins – who had already sung lead on the band’s songs “For Absent Friends” and “More Fool Me” – would provide lead vocals for the entire next album.

Accounts seem to differ on whether Phil Collins was now intended to be the permanent lead vocalist or was filling in until they did settle on a new one. Still, the positive response to the album A Trick of the Tail (1976) led them to keep Phil Collins as lead singer. Guitarist Steve Hackett left in 1977, and Mike Rutherford took over the additional guitar duties in the studio while continuing to play bass. Daryl Stuermer joined the touring band, sharing guitar and bass duties live without becoming an official member of Genesis.

#1 – Pink Floyd

By the time they released the multi-media monster The Wall in late 1979, bassist/vocalist Roger Waters had all but assumed control of Pink Floyd. They stayed on that course, as the follow-up release The Final Cut (1983) was essentially a Roger Waters solo album (on which longtime Floyd keyboardist Richard Wright doesn’t even appear), with the title suggesting that Roger Waters had meant for the record to close the book on the legendary band. However, several years later the other members – guitarist/vocalist David Gilmour and drummer Nick Mason, with Wright returning as a session player during the recording – released a new studio album entitled A Momentary Lapse of Reason under the band’s name.

No full-time replacement for Waters was added to Pink Floyd. Tony Levin played bass guitar and Chapman Stick on A Momentary Lapse of Reason, while Gilmour also handled some bass parts. Guy Pratt was then recruited as bassist for the stadium tour that followed. The whole period was weighed down by a messy and complicated legal dispute in which Roger Waters challenged the others’ continued use of the Pink Floyd name. It was ultimately settled out of court, with Gilmour and the others continuing to use the name.