10 Most Heartbreaking Songs About An Ex

Alice Cooper for an article about heartbreaking songs about an ex

Feature Photo: Geoffrey Clowes / Shutterstock.com

Some breakup songs hit harder than others. The 10 songs on this list come from very different corners of rock and roll, but each one deals with the pain, anger, regret, or loneliness that can remain after a relationship ends. From the Ramones and Bruce Springsteen to Linda Ronstadt, Alice Cooper, Grand Funk Railroad, and Elvis Costello, these are songs that can still hurt no matter how many times you’ve heard them.

# 10 – “Listen to My Heart” – Ramones

This may not sound like a heartbreaking song at first, but listen closely to Joey Ramone’s phrasing and the pain is right there. “Listen to My Heart,” from the Ramones’ self-titled 1976 debut album, turns rejection into a burst of punk-rock frustration, with Joey insisting that next time he will trust his own instincts instead of getting hurt again. Recorded at Plaza Sound in New York City and produced by Craig Leon, the track is driven by Johnny Ramone’s guitar, Dee Dee Ramone’s bass, Tommy Ramone’s drums, and Joey’s unmistakable voice. It lasts barely more than a minute and a half, but that is all the Ramones needed. For more on the band, see our Top 10 Ramones Albums, Complete List of the Ramones Band Members, and Complete List of Ramones Albums and Songs.

# 9 – “I Wish I Were Blind” – Bruce Springsteen

Bruce Springsteen’s “I Wish I Were Blind,” from his 1992 album Human Touch, gets right to one of the worst parts of a breakup: seeing the person you still love with someone else. The arrangement is restrained and lets Springsteen’s weary vocal carry the song, while the title says almost everything you need to know about the narrator’s state of mind. There is no anger or revenge fantasy here, just the helplessness of wanting not to see what is directly in front of you. It is one of Springsteen’s most painful songs from the period and one of the clearest fits on this list. The Brooklyn Bridge’s “Worst That Could Happen” approaches a similar situation from another angle, which is one reason these two songs belong together here. Fans can also visit our Top 10 Johnny Maestro and the Brooklyn Bridge Songs.

# 8 – “Don’t Toss Us Away” – Lone Justice

“Don’t Toss Us Away,” from Lone Justice’s 1985 self-titled debut album, is built around the desperation of trying to save a relationship when the other person already seems halfway out the door. Written by Bryan MacLean of Love, the song found a remarkable interpreter in Maria McKee, whose vocal gives the song its mix of pleading, anger, and disbelief. Lone Justice’s country-rock sound keeps the arrangement grounded while McKee pushes the emotion to the front. What makes the song so heartbreaking is that it does not come from someone who has accepted the breakup; it comes from someone still fighting against it. That moment, when one person is begging for another chance while the other has already made a decision, is what gives the song its power.

# 7 – “Something in the Air” – David Bowie

“Something in the Air,” from David Bowie’s 1999 album ‘hours…’, is one of the quieter breakup songs on this list. Bowie and Reeves Gabrels wrote the track, and the music moves with the same unsettled feeling as the story: a relationship is over, the other person is gone, and the room itself seems different because of that absence. Bowie does not need to turn the song into a huge dramatic performance. The small details do the work, especially the sense of looking around and realizing that someone who used to be part of your everyday life is no longer there. That mixture of emptiness, bitterness, and resignation makes “Something in the Air” one of Bowie’s most underrated songs about a relationship coming apart.

More David Bowie articles: 10 Essential David Bowie Love Songs; Complete List Of David Bowie Albums And Discography; Top 10 David Bowie Songs; 10 Best David Bowie Tin Machine Songs; Stevie Ray Vaughan David Bowie Tour: Why It Never Happened; Top 10 David Bowie Albums; 10 Most Underrated David Bowie Songs; 10 Best David Bowie Songs.

# 6 – “I Still Miss Someone” – Linda Ronstadt

Linda Ronstadt Heart Like A Wheel LP - Capitol Records 1974 - Near Mint Vinyl - Don Henley - Glenn Frey - Tim Schmit - Maria Muldaur

Linda Ronstadt recorded “I Still Miss Someone” for her 1971 self-titled album Linda Ronstadt, not Heart Like a Wheel. Written by Johnny Cash and Roy Cash Jr., the song is a simple statement of something almost everyone who has lost a relationship understands: life goes on, but one person can remain impossible to forget. Ronstadt’s version does not need an oversized arrangement or dramatic interpretation; her voice carries the loneliness. The song was already a country standard by the time she recorded it, but she made it fit naturally into the country-rock world she was helping define in the early 1970s. Of all the songs on this list, “I Still Miss Someone” may express its subject most plainly. There is no complicated explanation and no attempt to pretend the loss is over. She still misses someone. That is the whole heartbreak.

# 5 – “I Never Cry” – Alice Cooper

Alice Cooper’s “I Never Cry,” released in 1976 on Alice Cooper Goes to Hell, was a dramatic change of pace from the theatrical shock rock that had made him famous. Written by Cooper and Dick Wagner and produced by Bob Ezrin, the song strips away much of the character and spectacle and leaves Cooper sounding exposed and vulnerable. The repeated insistence that he never cries works because the listener can hear how much pain sits behind the statement. Cooper later connected the song to the alcoholism he was struggling with during this period, which gives the performance another level of sadness. On a list about former relationships, “I Never Cry” works less as a literal account of one specific breakup than as a song about loneliness, emotional damage, and trying to hide how badly you have been hurt. That contradiction is what makes it one of his greatest ballads.

Read More: Top 10 Alice Cooper Songs

# 4 – “Bang Bang (My Baby Shot Me Down)” – Vanilla Fudge

Vanilla Fudge took Sonny Bono’s “Bang Bang (My Baby Shot Me Down),” first made famous by Cher in 1966, and turned it into something much heavier and stranger on the band’s 1967 self-titled debut album. Where Cher’s original and Nancy Sinatra’s famous interpretation emphasize the song’s haunting simplicity, Vanilla Fudge stretches the heartbreak into psychedelic drama. Mark Stein’s organ and vocals, Vince Martell’s guitar, Tim Bogert’s bass, and Carmine Appice’s drums give the song the oversized sound that defined the band. The basic story is still painfully simple: someone who once loved you no longer does. Vanilla Fudge just makes that loss sound enormous, turning a concise pop heartbreak song into a dark, heavy performance that feels as if the relationship is collapsing in slow motion.

# 3 – “Heartbreaker” – Grand Funk Railroad

Grand Funk Railroad’s “Heartbreaker,” written by Mark Farner and released on the band’s 1969 debut album On Time, brings a completely different sound to heartbreak. This is not a quiet ballad or a reflective look backward. Farner sings with the kind of hurt that turns into anger, while Don Brewer’s drums and Mel Schacher’s bass give the song the weight that made early Grand Funk so powerful. The track is bluesy, heavy, and direct, and that is exactly why it works here. Some breakup songs leave you sitting alone with the memories; “Heartbreaker” sounds like the moment when sadness finally becomes frustration. It never became one of the band’s biggest singles, but it remained an important early Grand Funk song and a reminder that heartbreak can sound just as convincing through a loud amplifier as it does through a piano.

# 2 – “God Give Me Strength” – Elvis Costello and Burt Bacharach

“God Give Me Strength” brought Elvis Costello together with Burt Bacharach for one of the most devastating songs either man ever recorded. Written for the 1996 film Grace of My Heart and later included on their 1998 album Painted from Memory, the song combines Bacharach’s sweeping melodic sense with Costello’s gift for writing about jealousy, bitterness, and emotional collapse. Costello does not sing it like someone calmly remembering an old relationship. He sounds as if he is still trapped inside the loss, asking for the strength to get through it while anger and longing keep fighting for control. The sophistication of Bacharach’s arrangement makes the pain feel even sharper. This is heartbreak written by two master songwriters who understood that losing someone can bring out emotions that are not pretty, simple, or easy to explain.

# 1 – “Worst That Could Happen” – The Brooklyn Bridge

I wonder how many people out there, just like myself, simply can’t listen to this one. It’s just too painful. That’s why it’s at number one. Written by Jimmy Webb and released by The Brooklyn Bridge in 1968, “Worst That Could Happen” reached No. 3 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1969 and gave Johnny Maestro one of the defining performances of his career. The story could hardly be more heartbreaking: the woman the narrator still loves is marrying someone else, and although he understands that it may be the best thing for her, it is the worst thing that could happen to him. Maestro’s voice, the brass, the strings, and the escalating arrangement turn that realization into three minutes of pure emotional damage. Plenty of breakup songs are sad, but this one feels almost unbearable, which is exactly why we placed it at the top of the list.

Read More: Top 10 Jimmy Webb Songs